Don't cry for me Argentina
EM has started off the new year in the doldrums ...
For those who felt that 2014 would be nothing more than a mere
continuation of 2013 - steady improvement in the US economy, strong
corporate earnings and blockbuster equity performance, continuation of
Fed tapering etc. - last week's EM "double-whammy" certainly represented
a rude awakening.
First, there was HSBC's manufacturing Purchasing Manager Index (PMI) report on China,
essentially a barometer for business confidence in the world's secod
largest economy. Though markets were expecting somewhat of a cooldown
in sentiment, nothing prepared them for the PMI to drop below 50 - the
dividing line between "expansion" and "contraction" territory. At a time
when concerns about Chinese growth remain widespread, this report
certainly struck a raw nerve.
Second, Argentina allowed its peso currency (ARS) to depreciate intraday by the most in over a decade. By market close on Thursday,
ARS had depreciated past 8 per USD (for context, at the start of
January one USD bought just 6.5 pesos). Now, you may be asking: why all
the paranoia about Argentina, a country that's already been a financial
pariah for 13 years and a known no-go destination for most investors?
The reason is, it's not about Argentina at all. Rather, It's about how
symptomatic Argentina's problems are of the still-investable emerging
markets: Turkey, Indonesia, South Africa, India etc.
You
see, the reason the ARS has been on a slippery slope has to do with
Argentina's persistent external imbalances. On the one hand, the country
needs a large amount of dollars to pay for imports and to service its
huge debt load. On the other, due to 25% inflation and a government with
scant respect for property rights, few investors are supplying any
dollars to the country, and Argentina's foreign reserves have been
dwindling at a very fast pace. A perfect recipe to force your currency
lower.
Now,
the "still-investable" countries I listed above share many of the same
characteristics as Argentina. They're all facing current account
deficits (aka. income leaving the country exceeds income coming into the
country). Some, especially Turkey, also have perilously thin
international reserve buffers with which to defend their currencies. For
now, the one thing keeping these countries afloat is the fact that they
still have access to international markets - i.e. foreign investors are
still willing to put their money there for the time being. But any
prolonged crisis of confidence could change that very quickly...
Our view continues
to be as we outlined in our last macro post in 2013: it's important to
differentiate between individual emerging economies. Focus your
investments on those that are pursuing structural reforms, laying
the foundations for sustained growth, and have a large stock of
international reserves (China, Mexico, or if you're ready to stomach
some more volatility, Brazil). Steer clear of the likes of Turkey,
Indonesia, India, and South Africa - these countries remain far too much
at the mercy of international investor sentiment, with insufficient
tools to cushion the impact of boom and bust cycles. While none of them
are quite Argentina yet, several of them are certainly moving in that
direction.